Contact Us
Name:
Email Address:
Phone Number (optional):
Subject:
Message:
 
 
FAQs Contact Us Contact us
Sign in
Email Address
Password
small business login arrow  Forgot Password?
 
 
Serial Entrepreneur and Go BIG
Founder Wil Schroter's Blog!
Maybe your idea just sucks
Author: Wil Schroter
Friday, January 5, 2007

Are you an entrepreneur with a business idea that just can’t seem to get the support you deserve? Maybe you’ve completed a business plan but no one seems to want to read it. Or you’ve created a fantastic product that no one seems to want to buy. Perhaps you’ve pitched dozens of investors and no one seems to want to put money into your deal.

Or maybe, just maybe - your idea just sucks.

We’d all like to believe that we are a fountain of brilliant ideas, but let’s face facts – we’re not. Even the most brilliant business minds come up with a few duds from time to time. The challenge is to know how to identify the ideas that are the next big thing and to run like hell from the ones that just suck!

Know when to say when

Sometimes the best thing an entrepreneur can do is hit the “eject button” on a business idea as early as possible. Holding on to a crappy idea for too long hurts you at a couple of levels.

First, you’re probably running around to all of your contacts trying to get them excited about your new idea. You’re talking to investors, partners, potential employees, and such. The lasting impression that you’ve now created for all of your potential partners-to-be is that you are that dude with the crappy idea that wants to do business. You’re branded like the village idiot.

Secondly, you’re wasting valuable time that could be better spent on coming up with a better idea. We tend to hold on to ideas so tightly that we get very anxious about abandoning them. It’s as though if we admit that we were wrong about one idea that we couldn’t possibly have another one.

The truth is that you’ll probably have a whole bunch of crappy ideas, and if you’re lucky just one good one. There’s no reason to think that this one idea has to be the one that will spawn the next Google. If you’re smart enough to come up with one idea you should be smart enough to come up with some more. Let this one go and get on to the next one.

Don’t believe in fairytales

We all read these inspiring stories of entrepreneurs who go against all odds and are told “no” by everyone only to overcome these objections and create great companies. Unfortunately this is often a story that is much romanticized and rarely happens.

I remember the quote from Sam Walton, founder of Wal-Mart that went “"I guess in all my years, what I heard more often than anything was: a town of less than 50,000 in population cannot support a discount store for very long."

We then contrast that to the resounding success of Wal-Mart and think “there’s no way I could have a bad idea, look what happened to Wal-Mart when everyone told Sam Walton his idea sucked.” We use stories like that as an affirmation that we can simply ignore all of the negative feedback we’re getting and press on anyway.

Don’t let those stories fool you. While many entrepreneurs are told early on that their ideas are ludicrous the reality is that many of them really are. You only read about the ones that actually made it, not the ones that left the founder broke and insane drinking out of an alley somewhere (although that would make a pretty interesting story, too!)

Take a hint

There are lots of people who will ignore what you’re trying to do and write you off. That’s the way business goes. But the people that actually do listen to you and provide advice or comments that you don’t want to hear are the ones you need to listen to most closely.

If a customer says they don’t want to buy, the reason they don’t want to buy is incredibly valuable. Don’t write those reasons off as “this guy is an idiot” and assume you’re correct. If the customer is saying “no” to your idea or product, you’re the one who’s wrong, not the customer. Great companies aren’t built on the premise of calling of their customers idiots.

Smart entrepreneurs are confident enough in themselves to be able to admit when an idea isn’t going to work. They are so eager to find the “right” idea that they look at pursuing the wrong idea as a failure.

Look, it’s OK to have some crappy ideas - everyone has them. You simply need to take a long, hard look at the big idea in your head right now and ask yourself “If I jump out of a plane with this idea, do I have a parachute or a bag of bricks strapped to my back?”




Trackbacks to this story
There are no trackbacks...

Comments About this story
As my friend Andy Birol puts it, good ideas don't need angels.
Posted by: Scott Allen 1/24/2007 at 1:25 PM

Oh... I just remembered this from The Onion -- this is a hilarious look at this issue:

Ridiculous Small-Business Plan Encouraged By Friends

Here's the even funnier part... when I first posted this in one of the social networking sites (nameless to protect the guilty), several people posted their empathy for this woman -- they completely didn't get that it was satire. Yikes!
Posted by: Scott Allen 1/24/2007 at 1:29 PM

What? No links in comments? Hmm... would be nice to at least let the poster know so they don't end up with silly-looking comments like the two above that just don't make sense without the link. I know it probably helps reduce spam marginally, but it also reduces useful references in comments.

http://entrepreneurs.about.com/cs/financing/a/angelsnotneeded.htm
http://www.theonion.com/content/node/39174
Posted by: Scott Allen 1/24/2007 at 3:33 PM

I agree with most of what you wrote, but I think that you did oversimplify one point: from what I've seen, almost all ideas suck at first.  People who listen to the constructive feedback and monitor customer/user response either abandon their ideas and start over  (as you suggest) or modify their ideas until they evolve into something less sucky.  Both can be good choices under various circumstances.
Posted by: david 4/25/2007 at 10:01 AM



Add a Comment (Not logged in)  Register / Login

Name:
 
Email Address:
 
Homepage:
  (ex. http://www.gobignetwork.com)

 

Enter the Text in the Image Below (to confirm you're not a robot)

 


(Wil is immediately notified of your comment)

 

Recent Updates
Archive O' Knowledge
The Book
GoBig or GoHome Thumbnail

Go BIG or Go Home

Learn how the next generation of startup companies grow BIGGER and FASTER than anyone else. Real insights and actual strategies to grow your startup company like crazy. Required reading for anyone who loves startup companies and wants to get an edge.

 Buy the Book (e-book or paperback)
Blogroll
Premium Sponsors
Advertisement
© Copyright 2008 Go Big Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved
A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z