Contact Us
Name:
Email Address:
Phone Number (optional):
Subject:
Message:
 
 
Contact Us Contact us
Sign in
Email Address
Password
small business login arrow  Forgot Password?
 
 
Serial Entrepreneur and Go BIG
Founder Wil Schroter's Blog!
Someone Already Thought of My Idea - Now What?
Author: Wil Schroter
Friday, May 18, 2007

Last night you woke up at 3 a.m. with the best new business idea you've ever had.

You ran to your computer, started Googling similar terms, ran through Technorati to see if anyone was blogging about it, and performed some domain searches on GoDaddy to see if anyone had the name (they always do.)

You went to bed feeling good about your new idea, not finding anyone that had something similar.  You slept like a champion, basking in the glory of your brilliance.

Then you woke up the next day only to find an e-mail sitting in your inbox from a buddy you sent the idea to at 4 a.m.  It's a link to a site that does exactly what you had thought of.

Oh $&*@#! - someone already thought of your idea - now what??

Don't sweat it.  You don't have to be the first one to think of a good idea in order to make a great company happen.  There are plenty of ways to improve the idea and make it work.

Execute Better - Anyone could have sold books on-line, but Jeff Bezos of Amazon did it better than anyone.  Do not overlook the power of good execution.  There are plenty of good ideas that are executed poorly.  You can take just about ANY product category and likely do better than most competitors, if not all of them.

Narrow the Focus - Your competition is looking broad at lots of categories.  Narrow your focus to one category that you know you can dominate.   Determine whether customers care about a big, broad play or just one highly focused play.

Go Head On - Most companies do not handle competition well.  If it looks like there is only one other company in your space, is there any reason you can't make them #2 in short order?  Just because they are the only game in town doesn't mean they can maintain a #1 spot next to your competition.  Maybe they are just #1 because no one has beaten them at their own game.

Give it a Spin - Similar to narrowing the focus, another way to shape your idea is to shift the spin a bit.  NetFlix took an old model of DVD rentals and put the on-line browsing / through-the-mail delivery approach.  Ironically Blockbuster then gave the NetFlix model another spin and allowed you to return your movies the same day to their stores like NetFlix could not.

As I've said before, execution is what makes an idea great, not just novelty.  It's OK if someone has thought of your idea.  The real question should be - "Does the person who's thought of my idea have a better shot at making it #1 than I do?"




Trackbacks to this story
Someone Already Thought of My Idea - Now What? - This post Someone Already Thought of My Idea - Now What? is a few months old, but I just came across it tonight. it makes some very good points about a problem I think many of us have - we want to come up with that brand new, perfect idea, that no one...
From: FredSpace | 8/9/2007 at 10:23 PM

Comments About this story

You might even be pleased to find competition.  A competing service, complete with users of its own, means that there is a market for your service.  Eric Sink makes the case that we should choose competition wisely rather than avoid it all together:

http://software.ericsink.com/Choose_Your_Competition.html
Posted by: Tim Freund 5/18/2007 at 9:23 AM

Thanks Wil for this article! This is exactly the tonic I needed. I am about to start my company in a space occupied by one other company with a huge presence. While I was still going forward with my venture with a "spin", it was nice to hear from someone like you that taking on a much larger company is indeed doable.
Posted by: Arindam G. 5/18/2007 at 11:25 AM

Remember, according to the gospel of Wil, do not market your idea as the "insert huge company name here" killer. 
Posted by: Erick S. 5/18/2007 at 2:57 PM

When you have an innovative product and you are changing habits competition is great. For instance, my company <a rel="NOFOLLOW" href="http://www.pumpone.com">PumpOne</a> puts visual workouts on to iPods.

We need to teach people how to look to their iPod for exercise guidance. We feel that our product is the best in the space and sufficiently different from the competition. Once habits are changed people will gravitate to the best product, hopefully ours.

So in a new space, with an innovative concept competition will actually grow your market, or at least bring them closer.


Posted by: Mike 5/19/2007 at 1:29 PM

Great point... I have been an angel investor for last five years, and I think entrepreneurs always feel they have a "unique" idea... and there is a 95% chance that its not unique, or just a variation of something done before. I think the idea of "being unique" is a process not a product... in order to really be competitive long-term you need to have a certain pace and direction for you to out-innovate competition.  All great companies start off in a "crowded space", but the ones that last are the ones that out-innovate and grab the market share

rich
<a rel="NOFOLLOW" href="http://www.fastpitchnetworking.com">Business Networking</a>
Posted by: Rich 5/21/2007 at 1:42 PM

Wil's right.  There's room enough for all of us!  You should embrace the competition, bear-hug your customers (and his) and execute, execute, execute like a lean mean bottom line driven machine.
Posted by: John N. 5/24/2007 at 11:14 AM

My idea already has huge business and fierce competition. And I welcome the competition as I believe it will only bring more attention to the business concept and am building the plan with this in mind.

Fear of competition in my humble opinion should not be allowed to stop or slow you down from reaching out and achieving your goals.

For me I am happily taking on the big guns in the industry of choice. Why because I think our offer has many advantages that the competetor just doesn't have.
Posted by: jeff s. 11/6/2007 at 9:21 AM



Add a Comment (Not logged in)  Register / Login

Name:
 
Email Address:
 
Homepage:
  (ex. http://www.gobignetwork.com)

 

Enter the Text in the Image Below (to confirm you're not a robot)

 


(Wil is immediately notified of your comment)

 

Recent Updates
Archive O' Knowledge
The Book
GoBig or GoHome Thumbnail

Go BIG or Go Home

Learn how the next generation of startup companies grow BIGGER and FASTER than anyone else. Real insights and actual strategies to grow your startup company like crazy. Required reading for anyone who loves startup companies and wants to get an edge.

 Buy the Book (e-book or paperback)
Blogroll
Premium Sponsors
Advertisement
© Copyright 2010 Go Big Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved
*Each investor listed in GoBigNetwork as a potential funding resource for members must be an “Accredited Investor” as that term is used in federal and state securities laws. To be listed, every investor must supply qualifying information, and certify that it meets all criteria for Accredited Investor status. GoBigNetwork provides a platform through which members and Accredited Investors may identify each other, but makes no actual or implied representations concerning the availability of any potential funding or funding resource GoBigNetwork neither effects nor attempts to effect any funding or business relationship between members and any listed investor, and nothing contained in this website should be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase a security. Members and accredited investors listed in GoBigNetwork are solely responsible for compliance such federal, state or local laws which may apply between them in any funding transaction. GoBigNetwork is compensated solely by membership fees and fees paid by Accredited Investors for the opportunity to be listed as potential funding resources.

A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z 
DE  OH
Crunch Profiles  Crunch Companies