Sign In Join Us!
Sign in
Email Address
Password
small business login arrow  Forgot Password?
 
 
Serial Entrepreneur and Go BIG
Founder Wil Schroter's Blog!
Your Equity Isn’t a Payment, it’s an IOU
Author: Wil Schroter
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Hello there young entrepreneur, I’m your investor.  Remember me?

I’m the guy that sat in front of your heartfelt and emotional presentation to raise capital for your business.  I listened closely to your entire plan, and made a few comments about what I didn’t think would work.  You of course ignored my comments and assured me that with the right amount of my money, you’d be able to solve all of your problems.

I wrote you a check, you spent the money, and those problems haven’t gone away. 

So aside from all of your promises of future riches, you haven’t paid me back.  And, you know, the reason I wrote you that check was to create more money than I started with, which hasn’t happened. 

You see – giving me equity in your company wasn’t a payment, it was an I.O.U. 

Your Currency is Worthless

Giving up that equity may have felt like a payment.  You may have felt like what you were giving up was an actual asset that had real value.  We signed agreements and created a currency that was backed by your promises and intentions.  I swapped my currency for yours.  Now yours is losing its value - fast.

You may have thought those promises you made were going to be forgotten about or displaced by other promises.  In fact they weren’t.  Unlike the currency I gave you, I couldn’t spend your promises to hire my friends, find a fancy office or buy everyone new laptops.  But you did.

Now I’m stuck holding the bag with the useless currency you gave me while you’re out trying to print new currency with even more promises.  I’m sorry, I’m not buying it.

Remember these Guys?

Perhaps you may have forgotten about our arrangement, but maybe you’ll remember these guys – your employees.  What?  You don’t?  Allow me to jog your memory.

You may recall an evening over more than a few beers when you convinced them to quit their existing jobs to go work for you.  You told them that even though they would be giving up a steady income with an existing company, the money they would make from the stock options you gave them would far outweigh the risks.

They went back to their families and took your sales story with them.  They convinced themselves and their loved ones that the opportunity you had for them was real.  Soon thereafter they were missing family dinners, soccer games, and any time they ever had with their friends.  They were pretty confident that you’d make good on that little I.O.U. you created after that last beer.

Just like me, they seem to be wondering what happened to all of those promises.  They’re wondering how you expected to pay them back for all of the investments they have made in you.  By now they’ve figured out that no return is going to pay them back for the time they’ve lost with their friends and family, but they sure would like to think a payout might help them create some more time in the future.

We’re Not Done Here

Maybe somewhere along the line you forgot the basic mechanics of an exchange, so let me re-educate you.  When I hand you something of value, in order for the exchange to be equitable, you need to hand me something back something of equal or greater value.  Unless we finish the exchange, which involves you giving me something of value, we’re not done here.

In fact, unless you give me something back at all, it’s not even an exchange.  It’s probably not theft but it’s certainly not charity, and I’m not feeling like Santa Claus right now, so it ain’t a gift, that’s for sure.

In order for us to complete this transaction, and in order for you to make all of your debts right, I need you to fulfill your promises.  I need you to dig down and find all of the energy, enthusiasm and focus you had when you accepted my check and think about getting that money back.

You’re not Alone

Although times are tough and you’re feeling the pressure, you may feel like you’re the one with everything to lose.  Truthfully though, you’re not alone.  You may be the most visible person in this transaction, but if you quit on us, we all lose.

It took all of us to start the exchange and write that IOU, and it’s going to take every one of us – your investors, your employees and even your customers – to make good on your big promise to us. 

We realize that you need us as much as we need you, so we’re here to support you in any way you need us to.  We just ask that you don’t forget about us, because we can absolutely assure you – we won’t forget about you.



Trackbacks to this story
There are no trackbacks...

Comments About this story
This article is a great example of why I won't accept outside money. I'd rather burn through all my personal cash and die trying than to have some IOU hanging over my head. As if I need any more pressures to deal with right now!
Posted by: Geezer 4/30/2008 at 9:20 AM

Geezer, if you burn through all your personal cash, then you and your family are broke.

If you otherwise invest a portion of your cash into your company and then bring in investors, all you stand to lose is the cash you invested in your company.  There is no IOU for the investors' money that you are personally responsible for in a typical C-corp investment.

The worst case is that the company goes bankrupt, which is much preferred over you personally going bankrupt.  That's the great thing about companies...they are separate legal entities (when properly formed.)  Bless America!

Wil is just pointing out that the hot seat can get very hot when investors don't realize a return on their investment.

Remember, it is what has transpired to that point that Wil is leaving out of the story.  It isn't like you get a check and then the next status update to the investor is that the money is gone and the business has failed.

So, I'm not actually sure there's much of a point to Wil's post.  Everything that transpires from the first handshake to the time the money is gone determines the relationship with the investor.  The angel investors I have been involved with are true gentlemen.  They know the game (better than you), and there are certain rules.  If they put undue pressure on their jockey they fell in love with when they wrote the check, they know they have no chance to win the horse race.

Personally, I would rather have to tell an investor that their bet was bad and the company should fold, rather than having to tell my wife that we are broke.
Posted by: Robert Yeager 4/30/2008 at 12:22 PM

I actually wrote this article as a reminder to myself that the cash we took at GotCast.com and the stock we've handed to employees at Go BIG and GotCast is a real debt that needs to be paid back.

What I wrote was a fictional account of how I would approach myself if I owed that debt without repayment.

Got some really interesting responses from this one.
Posted by: Wil S. 4/30/2008 at 12:56 PM

I am the guy in this article.  You are right on the money.  It is all about being an equitable trade.  Promises are worth nothing.  You have to deliver results.  That IS what you promised in the first place.  

That is why it is called equity.  
Posted by: M. 5/6/2008 at 10:22 PM

This kind of letter can be applicable to quite a few relationships, and not just a few of my friendships especially.

At some point, I stopped thinking of the fact that I was someone's friend as being that "IOU" and started making good on their investment.  Whether that was a random phone call or email or even visit, it was about paying it back in kind and not pretending that our relationship was worth the same.

Great article, and valuable in its versatility.
Posted by: Judd Exley 5/7/2008 at 9:03 PM

Wil,

Great blog buddy. I think this should be required reading each quarter for anyone and everyone who has given out options or who taken in outside cash.

It will be for me.

Colin Andrews Egbert

P.S. It's Friday night... I was about to take off from the office... maybe I'll just stay here a little longer.. haha.


Posted by: Colin Andrews Egbert 5/9/2008 at 8:45 PM

Classic, Love it !
Posted by: Debra W. Wednesday at 2:29 AM



Add a Comment (Not logged in)  Register / Login

Name:
 
Email Address:
 
Homepage:
  (ex. http://www.gobignetwork.com)

 

Enter the Text in the Image Below (to confirm you're not a robot)

 


(Wil is immediately notified of your comment)

 

Recent Updates
Archive O' Knowledge
The Book
GoBig or GoHome Thumbnail

Go BIG or Go Home

Learn how the next generation of startup companies grow BIGGER and FASTER than anyone else. Real insights and actual strategies to grow your startup company like crazy. Required reading for anyone who loves startup companies and wants to get an edge.

 Buy the Book (e-book or paperback)
Blogroll
Premium Sponsors
© Copyright 2008 Go Big Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved