Sign In Join Us!
Sign in
Email Address
Password
small business login arrow  Forgot Password?
 
 
Serial Entrepreneur and Go BIG
Founder Wil Schroter's Blog!
Your Idea Alone has no Value
Author: Wil Schroter
Wednesday, May 14, 2008

Your Idea Alone has no Value

Contrary to popular belief, great companies are not borne from great ideas alone.  We'd all love to think that if we could simply invent the next Post-It note, we could sit back and watch the cash tumble in. 

But if great ideas don't spawn great companies, what does?

The short answer is: you.  The longer and far more complicated answer is how you specifically position yourself and your company to execute on an idea.  Anyone who overhears your idea, has the same idea at the same time, or basically plans on doing anything similar, is already on the same playing field as you are. 

In order to differentiate yourself and your idea, you don’t need a patent or some proprietary method.  You need a focused plan that allows you to execute above and beyond your competition every day of the week.

Think of your competition like your favorite professional sports league.  There are dozens of teams which have talented players on them, but only one team that is going to perform better than everyone else.  Your goal is to build that team.

Focus on Execution

There is a massive chasm between having a great idea and executing flawlessly on a business model for a great idea.  Lots of people have great ideas, but very few people ever execute well on them. 

Execution isn’t just about showing up for work every day and punching a clock.  For the team that wins, execution is about going above and beyond the call of duty each and every day. 

It’s about reaching out to your customer when there are no problems just to see how they are doing.  It’s about releasing a product feature faster than your competitor even when you’re already ahead.  It’s being the first car in the parking lot in the morning and the last one to leave at night.  It’s doing what the guy next to you isn’t willing to do.

Service the Heck out of your Customer

Even a product that’s a total commodity, like food, can take on a whole new meaning when you compare the service that comes with it.  In your city there may be a hundred places where you can order a filet mignon, but only a handful that are considered top notch.

The difference is that the top restaurants understand that in order to differentiate their product, they need to rely on better service.  They pay attention to every detail of your experience, from the greeting you get at the host stand to whether you’re given a white or black napkin based on your pant color. 

Exceptional service is by no means a commodity.  It’s a rare and unusual thing that very few companies can deliver. Chances are your competition isn’t going to go the extra mile to service the heck out of your customer, which creates an incredibly powerful competitive advantage for you.

Find the Weak Spot

It’s not uncommon for a startup company to go toe-to-toe with a much larger company offering a very similar product.  On its face, it looks like the startup is at a severe disadvantage.  Surely the behemoth megacorp can provide better execution and better service with its vast resources than a scrappy little startup can.

If you were to try to compete against the behemoth on their own terms you’d get crushed.  That’s why startups tend to look for the weak spots in larger companies and exploit them.  You can easily differentiate your product from a larger company by focusing on stuff large companies mess up all the time. 

Unlike a large company, you can offer the personal service and attention your customers love and probably are missing from your bigger competitor.  You can leverage your speed by releasing new versions of your product faster and responding to market conditions more quickly.  You can offer talented managers founder’s stock while a big company can only offer another bonus plan.

Every weak spot that you can exploit is another way to add value to your idea.  Once you’ve identified the points, the more pressure you put on those weak spots, the more value you’ll build for your own product.

Tying it Together

Outmaneuvering your competition isn’t about doing any one of these things – it’s about doing all of them consistently.  If your idea is great and novel, the only guarantee is that it will be copied.  If it’s not, you have to wonder how great of an idea it really is. 

When your idea does get copied, the only thing you’ll be able to rely on is your team and your execution.  All of the points about going above and beyond the call of duty, servicing your customer, and exploiting the weak spots will soon be used against you.

The only defense against the next up and comer and the only way to consistently create value around your idea is to stick to fundamental execution.  Nothing else has value.





Trackbacks to this story
There are no trackbacks...

Comments About this story
Wil,
There must be some sort of serendipitous cloud in the air, hovering over me and settling around my head quite nicely.  I don't know that I could be reading this article at a better time.

I've got ideas, lots of 'em, like every other schlep out there of course, and I'm becoming well aware that my execution of these ideas is what's going to set me apart.  I'm not even a startup, I'm a sole proprietor trying to build my company into something that will someday require actual employees, and your advice is integral to my future.

Awesome article, awesome way to get it across.  You've reached a part of my psyche that both inspires me and bolsters my confidence while still urging me on to pull up my bootstraps and pack a lunch.

So, thanks for that.  Much appreciated.
Posted by: Judd Exley 5/14/2008 at 9:23 PM

Wil,

I can't tell you how many people contact my company looking for backing, yet won't share their ideas in fear of someone stealing them and running with it.

Ideas are worth the time put into them - usually a few seconds.  Execution and stick-to-it-ness is EVERYTHING.

Great post! Thanks!

- Mike
Posted by: Mike Michalowicz 5/15/2008 at 2:33 PM

Yes, I think you have such a very valid marketing point there: no small business can compete with the giant, but we can all give excellent customer service at no added cost. And I would rather eat out at Sid's burger shack with the staff really helpful than Mac's with everything so systemized.
Posted by: zowoco 5/16/2008 at 5:15 PM

Wil:

Right on the Money! The idea is only the first part and execution is the second and follow through is the final part. Customer service is the key to success with a new small enterprise.

Thanks for your blog - Appreciate it



Jeff

Posted by: Jeffrey B. 5/19/2008 at 12:35 PM

Exactly! I think execution on an idea is of utmost importance. Its called "getting the ball rolling".

I've set up a challenge for people who are interested in taking an idea one step further:

http://30dayproductchallenge.com


Posted by: Sohail 5/19/2008 at 12:37 PM

Excellent post!  I recently blogged about selling something people already buy before trying to execute the next big idea.  That way you have the cash flow and the brand to bring your idea to fruition.  
Posted by: Mike Freeman 5/19/2008 at 2:40 PM

Great advice! I think customer service is so core to a successful business - yet amazingly many large businesses have abandoned this principle and will be overrun by little startups that remember that customer's are central to success.
Posted by: David Mackey 5/21/2008 at 11:25 PM

I couldn't agree more. How often do we hear people who say they thought of that long before it was invented. If only I had... And that's the key! If only I had is 99% of the work!

I believe so much so that I myself also wrote about this a while back. Very similar to your post, I titled mine "Ideas are a Dime a Dozen". You can find the post at: http://www.followsteph.com/2006/09/08/ideas-are-a-dime-a-dozen/


Posted by: Stephane Grenier 5/22/2008 at 12:15 PM

Surely the behemoth megacorp can provide better execution

You would think but one of them sunk.

Experts built the Titanic. Amateurs built the Ark.

 

 

Posted by: Victor T. 5/29/2008 at 2:18 AM

Wil,

I'd take this a step further and point out that execution is what transforms a good idea into a successful business model. Many successful entrepreneurs have started out with one great idea only to have it mutate into another during the process of execution because of the realities of customer and market response. It's one of the great problems with the myth of the great idea. It looks great on paper, but without customers a great idea...or even a great business plan...is NOT a business.

Posted by: Shawn Hessinger 6/1/2008 at 9:33 AM

These are some really great tips! I have just finished reading the new book "The Answer" by John Assaraf and Murray Smith and they discuss some of these exact same ideas. I recommend it to any small-business owner.

I was also able to enter the Million Dollar Business Makeover that their company is hosting. It's a really great resource. They are giving away a million dollars worth of prizes and already I have won free downloads and a ticket to their conference in Las Vegas! If you want to check it out you can go to www.themilliondollarbusinessmakeover.com

-Sarah
Posted by: Sarah M. 6/2/2008 at 3:06 PM

The same holds true in the commercial real estate industry.
Investors come to my firm with an idea and nothing else and they get mad at me when I don’t write them a check on the spot.
This post is full of very interesting insights.

MasterPlan Capital LLC
Commercial Real Estate Investment Bankers
Privately and Institutionally Funded Commercial Mortgage Loans
Equity Financing
Asset Management
Apply Online at: http://www.masterplancapital.com
Quick Answers – Fast Closings Available

Posted by: Glenn F. 6/2/2008 at 5:59 PM

I completely agree that alone an idea has no power. You have to strategize and execute a plan, taking into action that idea. I think a great example of this type of thinking can be found in John Assarof's New Book The Answer. He's a serial entrepreneur who gives his keys to entrepreneurial success. He is a wizard - by far the most valuable text I've ever read. (http://www.readtheanswer.com/index.php?rta=blog). Any thoughts on any other great entrepreneurial texts?
Posted by: Corey Blum 6/10/2008 at 11:58 AM

Customer service is key. I started my online biz 8 years ago, closed it 3 years ago, and I am planning to restart the site. My problem wasn't that I didn't give good customer service. I didn't target the right audience. I didn't copywrite my ads. So I had few customers. Now I found out that there is software out there like glyphius. I am going to start small and grow my business.
Posted by: CJ 6/10/2008 at 1:16 PM

Wil,
 
I have learned that your comments regarding the ideas are correct.  No one wants to talk to someone with an idea, they are interested in people who have converted the idea into a business.  Also, many large companies have policies that prohibit the submission of unsolicited ideas.

But what does one do if they have an idea for an innovative technology product that uses existing technology and services to solve a problem.  Without a working product, you can not get a patent.  But in the case of technology products that bundle hardware, software and services, since it is not economical to build a working prototype, the product idea, specific functionality and problem that it solves in the market is what is important. 
 
If the product is not in the market and addresses a billion dollar problem, it would seem that the idea has some value.

How does an entrepreneur protect an idea (trade secret or proprietary information  that leads that is the very heart of the new business)?  Building a business means assembling a team... but how do you negotiate with team members when some may have existing relationships to go directly to VCs to pitch the idea?  Some ideas can be executed by larger companies in a fraction of the time it takes a startup. 
 
Your insights are very helpful.

Posted by: rob 6/12/2008 at 4:51 PM

Great advice Wil,

PDCA Holdings, LLC, is direct to many Accredited Investors searching
for viable opportunities and as our main objective, we devote much of our time interviewing the founder to ascertain their strengths regarding the probability for execution of his/her plan. A large percentage of entrprenuers simply do not have the skills required to put their plan into action and they normally will not accept this fact. Typically they flat refuse to step aside and will not appoint someone capable of this demanding task. Unfortunately...Their idea then dies on the vine!

If interested in having your project reviewed, please e-mail only the Executive Summary and we offer free  initial assessments. Should you require in-depth feasibility studies or additional due-dilligence studies, we often can be out-sourced more cost effectively than in-house. We currently provide these type services to Investment Banking firms, Angel and other investors as a fee-based service.

Thank you,
Tony Bright / CEO
Posted by: PDCA Holdings 6/14/2008 at 9:31 AM

Wil,

Great post!

Its easy to think of an idea, play with it for a little while, and maybe even turn it into a goal on your wall. Its much harder to follow through with your goal and accomplish it. You have to maintain complete and utter discipline. But how do you develop this discipline. You have to retrain how your mind works. One of the ways to do this is first understanding some important laws that really govern mental activity. Entrepreneurs need to learn these laws and retrain their minds for success.

1. The Law of Attraction

Neural research shows that when you think positively towards a certain idea or object, every time you think of it in the future, positive neural chemicals are released in your brain, influencing you to take a positive stance on whatever it is your are thinking about. The same happens with negative thoughts. Learn to control your mind and you will be able to accomplish anything, as well as be able to adapt to adverse situations. When you think positively, you will attract positivity, which leads to success. Negativity breed stagnation, fear, doubt, and more negativity (its a vicious loop effect).

2. Cause and Effect

We see the world of tangible phenomena; we don’t see the vastly greater world that gives rise to it. That vastly greater world is the world of cause. Newton used the principle of cause and effect as it operates in the physical, mechanical world as the basis of his laws of thermodynamics: every action has an equal and opposite reaction. What the science of Newton’s day did not yet grasp was that matter, energy and consciousness are not distinct and separate domains, but are all simply different frequencies along the same continuum. What they did not fully grasp, but science has now shown us, is that the principle of cause and effect applies not simply to the mechanics of matter, but to the mechanics of everything, including our thoughts. You must be practiced at creating the thoughts that will serve your business. The effect will come shortly after.

3. Law of Gestation

Ambitious businesspeople tend to be impatient. However, ambitious people must understand that patience really is a virtue. The Law of Gestation complements the law of attraction. It says that for every seed, there is a set gestation or incubation period, a specific span of time that particular seed needs to establish itself before it can unfold from the blueprint into fully realized physical form. Each of your goals is a seed itself. If you take the right steps and have the right mind frame, the tree with sprout.


For more awesome tips and information check out below...

Posted by: Ron T. 6/26/2008 at 5:03 PM

I agree with this article but add one key ingredient not mentioned. "Perserverance"
Posted by: K C. Friday at 5:03 PM



Add a Comment (Not logged in)  Register / Login

Name:
 
Email Address:
 
Homepage:
  (ex. http://www.gobignetwork.com)

 

Enter the Text in the Image Below (to confirm you're not a robot)

 


(Wil is immediately notified of your comment)

 

Recent Updates
Archive O' Knowledge
The Book
GoBig or GoHome Thumbnail

Go BIG or Go Home

Learn how the next generation of startup companies grow BIGGER and FASTER than anyone else. Real insights and actual strategies to grow your startup company like crazy. Required reading for anyone who loves startup companies and wants to get an edge.

 Buy the Book (e-book or paperback)
Blogroll
Premium Sponsors
© Copyright 2008 Go Big Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved